The Vice-President of La Societe Guernesiaise has criticised the identification of an agricultural field next to the Princess Elizabeth House as a potential site for future development.
The Committee for Health & Social Care says an urgent need for nursing accommodation has led them to identify the steep field between Vauquiedor House and the PEH as a potential site to build.
"Based on information seen so far, there would appear to be a strong case to be made in principle for more key worker accommodation on the Hospital campus, which is why policy S5 may be relevant to this situation,” said the President of the DPA, Deputy Victoria Oliver, yesterday.
For clarity: while, of course, key-worker housing is much needed and a challenge we have to tackle (urgently!), I am a member of HSC that does not support building on the green field valley site at the PEH. There can’t be a strategic case while the DoK stands, unfit for purpose. https://t.co/Mdpjd6Ec5H
— Tina Bury (@MsTinaBury) April 12, 2022
Pictured: Not all of HSC are in agreement about the use of the field, with Committee member, Deputy Tina Bury, publicly denouncing the idea.
It wouldn’t be the first time policy S5 has been used. Elizabeth College was able to change the use of Canada Court from offices to an education facility through policy S5 and the large Guernsey Electricity substation at Beau Sejour was developed this way as well.
Pictured: HSC says there is unmet demand for key worker housing in Guernsey.
Furthermore, the Vice-President of La Societe Guernesiaise, Trevor Bourgaize, said the idea doesn’t make sense.
“La Societe’s view is that we should not be building on greenfield sites, especially when there are buildings that are in need of demolition and rebuilding, it just does not make sense that this should happen,” he said.
“It’s the lazy way out really. It’s cheaper to build on a greenfield site and it shouldn’t be happening.”
Pictured: The President of HSC, Deputy Al Brouard, said: "Having suitable accommodation is key to [the Committee's] ability to recruit and retain all the varied health and social care roles required to run its diverse services.”
After hearing the latest idea pitched by HSC, Mr Bourgaize said the IDP guidelines seem too easy to circumvent.
“We had a situation with the Castel hospital recently, where somebody from P&R ‘off the cuff’ suddenly announced that ‘yes, they could build 90 houses on a greenfield site’, and then we hear the DPA say there are ways around these things.
“These guidelines are too easy to get around: that field is a wide-open area with distant views, this just gives the impression of urban creep.”
READ MORE….
OPINION: Building on agricultural land
HSC wants more staff units at PEH
Requête may propose key worker housing - but not on green fields
Comments
Comments on this story express the views of the commentator only, not Bailiwick Publishing. We are unable to guarantee the accuracy of any of those comments.