Monday 25 October 2021
Select a region

CCA courts controversy over its decision-making

CCA courts controversy over its decision-making

Tuesday 27 July 2021

CCA courts controversy over its decision-making

The Civil Contingencies Authority has consigned its pre-travel testing plans to the sidelines, however the senior politicians behind the decision-making are now facing questions around the distress and the financial expense caused by their "rudderless" policies.

The announcement of plans to scale back the border re-opening for fully-vaccinated adults within the CTA came despite the Bailiwick being urged to ‘learn to live with covid’.

It was announced on Friday that these ‘blue category travellers’ would have to provide a negative test 48-hours before travelling.

The CCA has now ditched that idea - which some islanders have been building or changing their travel plans around over the weekend - indicating that a different form of restriction will be announced today instead.

It follows widespread concerns that Guernsey residents could get stranded in the UK without anywhere to stay if they tested positive for covid-19, under the previously-mooted border policy. 


Pictured: The CCA has backtracked on its announcement at Friday's media briefing, citing community feedback and new information. 

Businessman and former Chair of the IoD John Clacy was among those to question what the CCA was trying to achieve with Friday's announcement, which was delivered without any of the finer detail to back It up.

"In order to make travel workable the CCA need to give detail on how any local people who test positive with the 48hr test can get back to Guernsey and isolate there. Otherwise, this change effectively rules out all travel for locals. Or have I missed something?"

Carolyn Oxburgh, who was a nurse throughout her career and most recently the Head of the Guernsey Chest & Heart Centre, felt let down by Friday's announcement. 

"I have spent months encouraging/vaccinating Guernsey residents as wished for only for them to now penalise the same people. Definitely not Guernsey Together! We should test all local residents on arrival in Guernsey and others before departure!"

"One feels that this is all being drawn up on the hoof by a rudderless and incompetent CCA"

Businessman and local resident Tim Chesney has been critical of the CCA's decision-making throughout the pandemic. He fears the CCA's response is crippling the island's economy with debt that will be saddled by the future generations for years to come. He is also concerned by the severe effects on people's mental health. 

“The virus will be circulating for ever, there will always be variants, it cannot be eradicated, and we must now get on with our lives and live with this virus in the way that we live with all other risks.

"If we don't do this now then when will we ever do it, or are we now fixed into some sort of nightmare doom loop living on a small rock under the control of a health dictatorship?”

Pictured: Prominent figures in Guernsey’s medical and business world took to Twitter to voice their concerns.

Reacting to the CCA's u-turn yesterday afternoon, Mr Chesney said that had deepened his concerns, not alleviate them.

"One feels that this is all being drawn up on the hoof by a rudderless and incompetent CCA, with no consideration being given to proportionality, little attention paid to practicalities, and with no regard to the continuing collateral damage being caused to the economy," he told Express. 

Explaining the CCA's decision yesterday, its Chairman Deputy Peter Ferbrache insisted the decision was based on evidence as well as public opinion. 

“We have listened but we have also examined the latest available information,” he said.

“As we all know the position continually changes with this virus and we need to be likewise adaptable, and as such the CCA took the decision this morning that the planned changes for this Thursday will not come into effect.”

Pictured: Islanders can expect further border controls, as alternative measures have been investigated.

More details on any further border controls and their implications will be published today. 

Sign up to newsletter



Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

Posted by Gary Blanchford on
Give them a break, so they make a minor blip, they are correcting it, it's not the end of the world, we have been extreemly lucky over here to be looked after so well.
To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?