Monday 08 August 2022
Select a region

50/50 States split revealed by email leak

50/50 States split revealed by email leak

Thursday 05 July 2018

50/50 States split revealed by email leak

Thursday 05 July 2018

The fractures within Guernsey's government have been laid bare after an email was mistakenly leaked, highlighting the divide between our elected States members.

An email was sent by Deputy Gavin St Pier, the President of Policy & Resources and the island's Chief Minister, to 20 other deputies, therefore excluding 17 others and the two Alderney representatives.

He invited those 20 deputies to "compare notes, and perhaps plan a little ahead" before the next States meeting, which Deputy St Pier said had "plenty of opportunities for mischief to be made." They would be meeting in Jimmy's Cafe, St James, during the morning of Friday 6 July to do this.

fractured gov screenshot

Pictured: An excerpt of the email sent by Deputy Gavin St Pier, which was shared with Bailiwick Express by Deputy Peter Ferbrache

Accidentally, however, Deputy Peter Ferbrache was included in the email group. Deputy Ferbrache has forwarded that email on to the media, saying he was prompted to share the statement because there was a "clear inference that 'we' the missing 19 cannot be trusted and may act mischievously".

"It seems to be government in secret. I do not understand that approach as I can only act in a direct manner," his email said.

"On the face of it that is not Deputy St Pier’s approach. It leads me to muse that I wonder if there have been other examples of such conduct. I invite an open and unequivocal response from him on this.

"Without a clear explanation Deputy St Pier’s position as our senior politician has been seriously undermined."

Rumour is currently circulating that Deputy St Pier is forming his own political party in secret, and some of the Deputies not included in the email chain suggested this may be part of it.

Deputy Carl Meerveld, who has himself formed what could be referred to as the States' first recent political party in the form of the Islanders Association, said: "I am reliably informed that Deputy Gavin St Pier is forming his own political party, however it is being established in secret, by invitation only, rather than openly and transparently as both the Charter 2018 group and Islanders Association has been formed".

In the ensuing email conversation between Deputies, groups such as the Islanders Association and Charter 2018 were accused of being divisive, but Deputy Meerveld argued those groups were formed entirely in the public eye.

Express approached Deputy Gavin St Pier for comment early this morning and he cc'd us into an open reply sent to everyone in the original email chain opened by Deputy Ferbrache.

Gavin st pier letter states divide

Who received the original email inviting them to the meeting at Jimmy's Cafe:

Of the 40 elected members of the States of Guernsey, which includes 38 Guernsey deputies and two representatives of the States of Alderney, 20 people received the invite to the meeting at Jimmy's from Deputy St Pier. 

They were:

Deputies Charles Parkinson, Michelle Le Clerc, Lyndon Trott, Jonathan Le Tocq, Jane Stephens, Barry Brehaut, Richard Graham, Matthew Fallaize, Mark Dorey, Shane Langlois, Jennifer Merrett, Lindsay De Sausmarez, Chris Green, Peter Roffey, Emilie Yerby, Rhian Tooley, Dawn Tindall, Sarah Hansmann Rouxel, Heidi Soulsby, Victoria Oliver and Al Brouard.

The ones excluded were:

Deputies Peter Ferbrache, Carl Meerveld, Barry Paint, Robert Prow, John Gollop, Marc Leadbeater, Joe Mooney, Lester Queripel, Jan Kuttelwacher, Paul Le Pelley, Neil Inder, Mary Lowe, Jeremy Smithies, Laurie Queripel, Andrea Dudley Owen and David De Lisle and Alderney Reps Louis Jean and Graham McKinley. 


Sign up to newsletter



Once your comment has been submitted, it won’t appear immediately. There is no need to submit it more than once. Comments are published at the discretion of Bailiwick Publishing, and will include your username.

Posted by Lisa Vahey on
Perhaps Deputy Ferbrache should have spoken to Deputy St Pier before 'blabbing' to the media.
Maybe this is the kind of 'mischievous behaviour' that Deputy St Pier was referring to?
Posted by John Semenowicz on
Dear Deputies

I would like to make it perfectly clear to all states deputies exactly where the Guernsey Whig Party stands in relationship to our local politics.

The Guernsey Whig Party (free membership) is an alternative to some of the political views held by deputies: Inder, Smithies, Queripel (both), Le Pelley, Meerveld, Leadbeater, Mooney, Kuttlewascher, Ferbrache, Paint, Prow and De Lisle. ( Many thanks to Neil Inder for providing us with this list on his facebook page)
To place a comment please login

You have landed on the Bailiwick Express website, however it appears you are based in . Would you like to stay on the site, or visit the site?